Podcast: Play in new window | Download | Embed
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Amazon Music | Android | RSS
Summary
Amy and Tricia continue their classical apologetics series, diving into discursive reasoning—the step-by-step thinking process that distinguishes humans as rational beings made in God’s image.
This conversation is a mental workout (in the best way possible!). The mamas unpack the difference between deductive reasoning and inductive reasoning. They emphasize that Christianity does not require blind faith—it calls us to love God with our minds and think well. With practical examples—from the cosmological argument to presidential debates, to lipstick on the wall—the mamas show how logic protects our children from being swayed by emotional manipulation and faulty reasoning.
This episode reminds us: Good thinking is discipleship. If we don’t train our children to evaluate arguments, culture will do it for us.
Main Points Covered
- Discursive reasoning and how it distinguishes human rationality
- Deductive vs. inductive reasoning
- Evaluating premises, hidden assumptions, and logical fallacies
- The cosmological argument as a real-world application
- Teaching children to think critically through everyday media and conversations
People and resources mentioned
Unfamiliar Vocabulary
- Discursive Reasoning – Step-by-step reasoning that moves logically from premises to a conclusion.
- Deductive Reasoning – Reasoning from general premises to a specific conclusion; if valid and sound, the conclusion is certain.
- Inductive Reasoning – Reasoning from specific observations or evidence to a general conclusion; conclusions are probable, not certain.
- Abductive Reasoning – Reasoning that selects the most likely explanation based on available evidence.
- Implicit Premise – An unstated assumption that underlies an argument.
- Explicit Premise – A clearly stated foundational claim within an argument.
- Fallacy – An error or mistake in reasoning.
- Cosmological Argument – A philosophical argument for God’s existence based on the need for a cause of the universe.
Quotable Quotes
The vast majority of things we know are through inductive reasoning. In fact, the whole scientific process, the scientific method, is built upon this notion of inductive reason. - Tricia Scribner Share on X Truth is about soundness… whereas validity is about the structure. - Tricia Scribner Share on X What is possible isn't necessarily what's reasonable. - Amy Davison Share on X
We are all in this together, so sometimes our posts are a bit of all of us.
