Recently I was sent a curriculum for a well-known ministry which has changed leadership and gone “progressive.” When I say progressive, I am referring to progressive Christianity, not progressive politics, although the two often overlap. (If you aren’t sure what progressive Christianity is, see here, here, and here.)
One of the earmarks of progressive Christianity is a refusal to talk about sin. The curriculum I reviewed was no exception. The word that is used in its place is particularly irksome 1) because it is so overused and 2) it paints a pretty awful picture of God. The word? Messy. What's one of the most overused pseudo-Christian buzzwords which turns God into a big germaphobe in the sky? Messy. Click To Tweet
“The woman at the well had a messy past.” “Christian community can be messy.” “Life is messy.” “Embrace your beautiful messy life.” I’m sorry, but no.
The exchange of one word for another is not a new tactic. In fact, we devote an entire chapter to this kind of propaganda in the upcoming Mama Bear Apologetics book. Chapter 4: Linguistic Theft—Changing Words to Get Your Way and Avoid Reality.
Why is culture making this shift? Why has it become so taboo to say the “s” word (sin—oops I said it…) And what kind of ground are we losing by excising this word from our Christian vocabularies? We’ll get to that. But first, let’s take a look at whether this word is ever warranted.
Is it ever appropriate to use the word messy?
We don’t want to go bashing on this new trend without looking at why this little word has become so fashionable. Often, the trends that irk us most are valuable because they are picking up on aspects of culture or blindspots in the church that we have missed and are attempting to address them, albeit not always in the best way. So when would it be appropriate to use the word “messy” instead of sinful?
1) When it’s in exchange for the word complicated
There are legitimate things in the Christian life that are complicated, and yes, even messy. Relationships between people can be strained from non-sin related issues, like two people who keep miscommunicating. Miscommunication is not sin. Or how about teens struggling to learn boundaries? Or trying to have a sex talk with your 8-year-old who just discovered that the website “snuggle buddies” was not referring to puppies?1Not a real website. I just made that up. So yes, there are legitimate parts of the Christian walk that can be messy.
2) As an invitation for further conversation
Nobody wants to start a conversation airing their dirty laundry. If you’ve got 30 seconds of a “Hi! How’ve you been?” kind of conversation, someone might use the word “messy” instead of explaining the full story of how they broke up with their girlfriend, ended up getting drunk and sleeping with a stranger and then stumbling into porn addiction. Saying a generic “messy” might open up future conversations without having to get into the full story during meet-and-greet time at church.
3) If a person has a religiously abusive background
There are some people, for whom the word sin carries a bit too much baggage. Maybe they were raised in a hellfire-and-brimstone church and the word sin brings back memories of angry preachers screaming from the pulpit? But messy… they can handle messy. They are willing to talk about that, and maybe along the way start facing issues that they have tried to bury.
I say this knowing full well that probably every person who uses the word messy is going to immediately cling to this point and say “Yes, that’s exactly why I use it!” But before you take a small subset of legitimate cases and rubber stamp them on every situation, continue on below to see why this word really isn’t a great idea and is, at best, a temporary substitution that needs to be replaced and/or defined ASAP.
Why we really shouldn’t use the word messy (and especially not with our kids)
1) Messy and sin aren’t even in the same ballpark.
As mentioned above, chapter 4 of the Mama Bear Apologetics book is dedicated to a technique I call linguistic theft and the reasons behind why people utlilize it. Two of those reasons are that it turns a negative into a positive (or in this case, downplays a negative) and it obscures the real issue. Are we all tainted by sin? Absolutely. Anyone who’s taken a kid through the terrible twos should be able to describe what unchecked original sin looks like in a child who is too young to control themselves.
Messy is much more palatable. But in the end, it risks whitewashing a major problem so that it sounds like a minor problem. It’s like calling pneumonia “the sniffles.” But times a billion. Some people excuse this verbal hijacking by claiming that it “speaks to the culture where they are at.” Really? You think our culture is that different from ancient cultures? I don’t think so. People didn’t like having their sin pointed out when Jesus was on earth, and they don’t like having it pointed out now. (John 3:19-21) So, while you may be able to “reach the culture” by getting them to acknowledge that they are “messy,” you won’t win them to Christ necessarily.
I’m guessing that the thinking is “If everybody is afflicted, why make people feel bad about it?” Sin sounds so harsh. So final. Messy sounds a lot nicer than sin. Nobody likes a messy person, but nobody would condemn them for eternity for it. Exactly, which brings me to my next three points… Come on, church. This is like calling pneumonia 'the sniffles.' Click To Tweet
2) It turns God into a giant neat-freak, germaphobe in the sky
One of the problems with interchanging the word messy for sin is that sin is the reason we are separated from God. What do you think a kid who hears this will conclude about God? That He prevents people from going to heaven because they are messy? As if God is a giant neat-freak germaphobe who can’t allow someone to mess up His house? What a weak, sniveling picture of God that paints. Now worship Him? No thank you. Worship a God who won't let you into heaven because you track your mess into His house? No thanks. (Just one reason why we need to stop using this word!) Click To Tweet
3) Hell sounds like total overkill.
Let’s replace the word sin with the phrase “being messy” in scripture. “For the wages of being messy is death.” Well that escalated quickly… And we wonder why people think God is a moral monster?Let’s replace the word 'sin' with the phrase 'being messy'. 'For the wages of being messy is death.' Yikes! Well that escalated quickly… Click To Tweet
4) It completely undermines the Gospel.
The gospel is literally translated “good news.” The thing about good news is that its felt goodness is directly proportionate to the felt badness. For example, someone might get the “good news” that they are cancer free. A healthy individual might think “Oh, that’s nice,” and then go about their day. However, a person who has already had cancer might throw an elaborate party with friends and family to celebrate the good news with them. It is quite a different story to be saved from cancer than it is to never have cancer in the first place. When we tell people that they were never sick with sin in the first place, the good news that they are free of sin is one giant “Meh.” When we tell people that they were never sick with sin in the first place, the good news that they are saved from their sin is one giant 'Meh.' Click To Tweet
5) It’s often used as a cover for rebellion
Let’s be honest. People would rather say that their life is messy rather than admit that they really don’t care that much about obedience or submitting to God. But this denial just compounds their “mess”: we can’t fix the problem if we won’t admit the problem, and our problems are often traceable to sin, not messiness. We need to stop trying to downplay the issues here. They’ll just snowball.
So how should we address sin with kids?
Bottom line, we need to be teaching our children about sin, not messiness. They need to know that what we have inside of us is a massive problem. It’s not that God doesn’t allow us into heaven because we’re messy. He can’t allow us into heaven because we are tainted with something terminally poisonous, and if we come into a perfect place still covered with this poison, then we poison everything around us. God can’t let a sinful person into heaven because it would cease to be heaven. It would turn right back into what we see here on earth. Live on this earth for eternity? No thanks. (In fact, I never understood those movies where people wanted to live forever. They must have a much more comfortable existence that I have.)
On the flip side, we don’t need to turn our innate sinfulness into an exaggerated form of “worm theology” where all we do is beat ourselves up and talk about how horrible we are. (Ohhhh, woe is us… We’re all just lowly worms swimming in our own filth in comparison to God’s glory…) Our children don’t need to hear that they are terminally broken with no hope, because it’s just not true. Yes, we are all tainted with sin, but we are also all created in God’s image and we have infinite worth in His eyes, In our discussions on sin, we can’t let our kids forget that! The human tendency is to emphasize one over the other, but the gospel doesn’t exist without recognizing both our sinfulness and our immense worth. That was the whole point of Christ coming to earth. Jesus didn’t come to prove how much better he was than us—make us all feel bad enough about ourselves that we are tricked into revering Him as Lord. No. He came to say “You have poison? I can get the antidote, but the price is my life. But you all mean so much to me that I freely sacrifice my life so that we can be together forever.” Christ valued us to the point that losing His life was worth the sacrifice. If that’s not worth feeling good about, I don’t know what is.
Want to learn more about talking with your kids about sin? Stay tuned for our next blog by guest blogger Beth Nyhart, author of the soon to be released Rend Your Heart & Not Your Garments: A plea to leaders of a church filled with secret sin.
Hillary Morgan Ferrer is the founder of Mama Bear Apologetics. She is the chief author and editor of Mama Bear Apologetics: Empowering Your Kids to Challenge Cultural Lies and Mama Bear Apologetics Guide to Sexuality: Empowering Your Kids to Understand and Live Out God’s Design. Hillary has her masters in Biology and has been married to her husband, Dr. John D. Ferrer, for 15 years. Don’t let her cook for you. She’ll burn your house straight to the ground.
Yes! I’ll be sharing this next week! I’m so thankful for discerning women who don’t mind cleaning up too much messy! Wonderfully written!
Yay! Thanks Rebecca!
So thankful to read something from a fellow sister in Christ that isn’t dripping with sugar and full of useless fluff! Praise God!
Ha! You’ll be hard pressed to find sugar and fluff here. There is a time and a place for that, but we think it’s time we start treating women as the tender warriors that they are and really equip them for the culture. It’s always encouraging when we meet another member of our “tribe,” — welcome Mama Bear. 🙂
excellent! Thank you for being bold and telling the truth in love, as we are commanded by God to do – sound biblical teaching! God bless.
Thank you for noticing! Our biggest goal is to be equally truthfully and loving: fair, balance, nuanced, but telling it like it is.
Hi, Hillary. I’m not a huge fan of the word “messy” either, but it certainly seems favorable to “terminally poisonous.” How about we’re all humans, capable of making good and bad choices? Even more disturbing, however, is the harm inflicted when a child must be convinced that he/she is “sick with sin” for the Christian message to be effective.
How would you describe sin and it’s ultimate effects? I’m not advocating for using analogies before a child is able to understand the concept of an analogy. But as Christians, if we pretend sin is just an oopsie, I don’t think we understand sin.
Also Janet, we need to distinguish between who we ARE and what we HAVE. We ARE created in the image of God. We HAVE a sin nature. There is a big difference. Teaching kids that our core itself is flawed tells them that it is unfixable. Teaching them that we HAVE sin — along with all of mankind — allows us to maintain the image of God while still acknowledging the brokenness in the world. Because one thing is certain: your kids WILL notice that there is something wrong with the world.
Thank you for this post. These are some excellent insights! I especially appreciated your treatment of “messy” as a replacement for “sin” in the context of Romans 6:23 and hell. I really resonate with not misconstruing God as a “moral monster.” It’s God’s amazing character of perfect love and justice which attracts and draws children (and adults) to Him. I think it’s really important to get our facts straight when communicating about sin and hell as to not cause any unnecessary stumbling blocks.
PS – I sent you a lengthier message commenting on this topic a bit earlier. Please disregard the first message and read the second one (I made a few edits and added a bit). I hope you get a chance to read it!